Ad
Ad

Downside to smart dog?

QUESTION:

What's the downside of having a smart dog?

answered by Jean Donaldson

ANSWER:

Surprisingly, there are quite a few. Smart dogs actually learn to "work" the system, and they pick up the naughty stuff just as quickly as they learn the good-behavior stuff. Most importantly, though, smart dogs are the most easily bored and understimulated.

Unfortunately, boredom and understimulation has serious welfare implications (think about how zoos get knocked for having unenriched environments for their captives). Severe problem behaviors can result, as the dog gives himself his own projects to do. Any dog, but especially the smart ones, need plenty of mental exercise.


Jean Donaldson is the founder of San Francisco SPCA's Dog Training Academy and author of numerous books, including Culture Clash.

Read more about Jean Donaldson in the DogTime expert center...

Ad
Road to Rescue

Comments

AvatarI'm very curious as to how someone who believes so whole-heartedly in Skinnerian behaviorism can call one dog "smart" and the other not... I suppose you'll offer that it must be a physiological difference. How can one dog be "smarter" than another, Ms. Donaldson, if they cannot choose or think on some level?

I suppose you believe that some dogs are just more easily conditioned?


— Eggs, May 20 2009

AvatarMs. Donaldson, given that you believe dogs are solely the product of Operant and Classical conditioning, I have to wonder what you believe makes a dog "smarter"? Since you do not believe they posses the power to comprehend or reason (even to a small extent), but rather can only be conditioned, I'm sincerely very curious as to how you can deem one dog "smart" and one dog not.” — Eggs, May 20 2009

Avatari wanted a smart yorkie pup but i didnt know that their where down sides to having a smart puppy but when you think about it i guess it would” — soccernb08, Aug 13 2008

Add a comment


newest topics:
Behavior
Subscribe to Behavior 197 topics, 791 posts
Button_topic_start topics replies views last post
Barking in Jeep

I love love love my 4 year old smooth-coated collie...so much that I purchased a Jeep so we can go for long drives and ride... (continued)

0 33 2 days ago by Alane
view
Young dog starting to exhibit posturing/aggression

Hello, I have a one year old Boarder Collie that used to be more scared/anxious around dogs when she was younger at lea... (continued)

2 77 Nov 5, 2009 9:01am by Stacey
view
Sleeping through the night

I have a seven month old golden retriever. He sleeps in a crate in our bedroom. He likes being in his crate as he often l... (continued)

0 218 Oct 27, 2009 10:51am by mubby
view
Barking when i leave

when anyone leaves the house and even if someone is still inside my dog will carry on and cry, bark and even howl, how can i stop him from doing this

2 239 Oct 22, 2009 11:30am by Dennis and R...
view
Welcome! | 11/08/09
Please Login or Sign up
Ad
dog photos