OK to leave dog in car? Dear Labby advises.

Dear Labby,

My friends are telling me that they bring their dogs everywhere they go - even for a dinner out - because they're too smart/vivacious/young/nervous etc. to leave at home for three hours. They say the dogs would prefer to be in the car knowing their owners will come back, rather than wait anxiously at home.

I don't leave my toddler wrapped in a fur coat in the car while I run my errands (nor would they), so why do they think it's ok for their dog? And is it ok to leave your dog in the car when the weather is not hot? How can I help my friends understand leaving them in the car is not better than the alternative and do so anonymously?

Signed:

I'm Naturally Concerned About Relegating Canine to Enclosed Ride And Thus Endangering Dog

You're very right to be concerned, as this is a matter of safety as well as etiquette. Clearly you've heard the reports of dogs who met their death after owners "innocently" left them in the Chevy for an hour. On a warm day, a car can quickly become an oven, and the results are fatal.

But myriad other things can go wrong as well. A dog left alone in a car, even in mild temperatures with cracked windows, is vulnerable. No one is immune from sudden severe weather or taunting 8th grade boys. Which is why I also hate to see dogs tied up outside restaurants, grocery stores, and coffee shops.

I sense your friends mean well, I.N.C.A.R.C.E.R.A.T.E.D., but they just don't have accurate information. That said, unsolicited doggie advice is about as welcome as a sharp stick in the eye, so an indirect approach may be your best bet:

"When Betty adopted her Papillon, the dog was so anxious, she even brought him into the bathroom with her. But the behaviorist showed Betty exactly how to make the dog feel comfortable and secure during his alone time. Now everyone is so much happier and the dog is mentally healthier too."

If that doesn't work, I recommend the direct approach. Send your friends any or all of the following articles:

And yep, you've got my blessing to do so anonymously.

Read all Dear Labby installments.

No comments about this page yet. Be the first!

Recent conversations on these topics

  • Neighbors dogs are constantly getting loose.

    Our neighbors have 2 moderately good sized dogs, who constantly climb over, or dig under their fence and get out. This happens a minimum of once a day. The fence that they keep escaping from is a mere 4 foot tall chain link fence; perfect for a small dog, but not for a big one. Our neighbors know their dogs can escape, and they are always running around the neighborhood in the attempt to round them up and bring them back home. My boyfriend and I have lived next to them for almost a year, and they have yet to attempt to ratify this problem. We have two dogs; a 7 year old cocker spaniel, and a 9 month old pitbull/boxer mix. Unfortunately, our yard is not fenced in yet, so we still have to leash our babies when they need to relieve themselves. While the "escapees" are friendly with our dogs and us, it is becoming quite a problem when they get loose and we are all outside. Our Pittie likes to play, and is very rambuncious if anyone, human or dog comes near her. Due to this, we are having to avoid taking her and our cocker out into OUR backyard; she gets excited, forgets to potty, and becomes very hard to control due to her strength. She is still a silly pup and not fully trained yet.Our cocker is nearly fully blind, and tends to get knocked over and into in the process of "play" between the "escapee" dogs and our pit. We are becoming very irritated that we have to plan our dogs potty breaks, outside visits, etc... around our neighbors dogs because they are irresponsible owners. We have thought about calling animal control, but we do not want to cause trouble with them; we will be living next to them for a long time, afterall. Do you have any suggestions as to what we should do about this? (At this point, I am almost more concerned about THEIR dogs' saftey than anything else.)

  • Tension between roommates due to dogs

    My roommates and I have recently moved into our apartment. I have a dog that is 55 pounds, 6 months old while my roommate has a 6 month old dog that is 3 pounds and the size of my dogs head. My puppy is playful yet gentle with her puppy and never shows agression towards it. However, she thinks their "nippiness" is too violent and is always worried her dog is going to get hurt. A few times her puppy yelped but thats because when they were running around mine accidently stepped on her dogs foot and my roommate freaked out over this. The two puppies always go to each other they're not enemies at all but she keeps hers on a tight leash and makes sure it's always within two feet of her, as if its a little infant next to a ferocious beast! If my dog actually wanted to hurt hers, wouldn't he have done so already? She is constantly complaining about my dog trying to play with hers and that its way too rough, it causes a lot of stress in our house. Can you give me any advice on how to deal with this situation or something to tell her that would reassure her they are just playing?

300x90Advertisement

Welcome to DogTime.com

DOGTIME LOGIN or SIGN UP

close