The emotional and cognitive lives of animals

Leslie Smith Editor in Chief of DogTime.com
Leslie Smith, Editor in Chief
Wednesday August 11th, 2010
  • Share on Facebook
Column_um_medium

My husband and I take turns trying to outdo each other with this question: Would you rather have five minutes in Uno’s head or a million dollars? No matter what the second choice is – eternal youth, incredible wealth, an unending supply of guacamole – a few moments inside the brain of our dog always wins.

It’s hard to believe that there are still those out there who would argue that animals don’t think and, even more astonishing, don’t feel. And while I don’t need science to tell me that my dogs experience thought and emotion, I’m thankful for the studies that prove it, thereby holding humans accountable for the way we treat animals.

If you’re not familiar with the research, a good place to start is the HSUS interview with two of the leading scholars in the field of animal emotion and cognition: Marc Bekoff and Jonathan Balcombe. Among their learnings: Elephants grieve. Bats display altruism. Birds feel depression. Hippos seek pleasure.

And that’s just the beginning. Read Bekoff's The Animal Manifesto: Six Reasons for Expanding our Compassion Footprint for a compelling, scientific account of why humane treatment of animals is our only ethical choice.

PS. To those that cry "Anthropomorphism!" -- assigning human characteristics to non-human beings -- I respectfully disagree. It may be difficult to prove that your dog truly loves you, but the same could be said of your spouse, your sister, or your best friend. What's much easier to prove, based on brain composition and testing, is that animals feel fear, joy, pain, and distress. Subtler nuances, which may well be unique to humans, are irrelevant.

vghaje

When my Jack was at his "bitter end" and the vet asked if I would stay or go as she administered the medication to save him from pain...I looked at my best buddy and saw the tear run down from his eye. Yes, animals fear, feel pain like humans, yes, but they understand more than humans. They have a "sense" beyond ours that lets them know our fear, our heartbreak. This dog could read my mind...see into my heart and loved me better than any friend I have ever known.

almost 2 years ago by vghaje

crittercreek93

Animals feel everything, just as we do. They experience the confusion of loss (a loved one who doesn't return), they experience sadness (they know when you're down) and who on God's green Earth can even suggest that they don't feel pain? If their loved ones are miserable, they're at a loss to fix things for us. Yes, they feel. They feel EVERYTHING.

almost 2 years ago by crittercreek93

Monita

I definitely agree!! Animals have emotions and most definitely feel pain.

almost 2 years ago by Monita

Editor's Notepad
Square_50_screen_shot_2012-05-23_at_11.49.36_am

by Leslie Smith on May 23rd, 2012

Sgt. Nick B was on patrol when he noticed the skinny dog, covered in mud, scavenging for food.

Square_50_chained_dog

by Leslie Smith on May 14th, 2012

For some, the issue of over-crowded shelters is easily fixed. Just stop the killing. Realistic?

Square_50_screen_shot_2012-05-09_at_9.28.16_am

by Leslie Smith on May 9th, 2012

Pit Bull pulls her unconscious owner out of the way of a speeding train, suffering grave injuries.

Square_50_botox

by Leslie Smith on May 2nd, 2012

I volunteer at an open-admissions shelter. What do I say when someone asks me if I "kill dogs"?

See all Editorial Posts »
AD
Wahl-300x90-banner-flat

Welcome to DogTime.com

DOGTIME LOGIN or SIGN UP

AD
AD