The Best Vibrating Dog Collars For Gentle Pet Training
Not ready for shocks? These vibrating dog collars produce similar training results without the use of physical pain.
Dog training can be a difficult task. Some pups do well with bite-sized treats, while others require more intervention. Vibrating dog collars are an excellent tool for effective, pain-free training. They put out a mixture of beeps and vibrations when your pet does something wrong. They’re typically controlled via remote, leaving you with all of the training power. And along with producing quick results, they’re fairly easy on the wallet. Read on to discover some of our favorite vibrating dog collars from Amazon today.
Best Vibrating Dog Collars to Consider
Before you purchase a vibrating dog collar, there are a few questions that you will want to consider. First, try to think about all of the efforts that are going into training your pup. It’s important to not only use a vibrating dog collar, but also a combination of other practices. This should include positive rewards, such as treats or bones. If you’re looking for a quality dog treat, these blueberry-based treats are great options.
Next, make sure the collar you choose fits your lifestyle. You will want to look into the range, for example, to make sure it’s long enough to work from anywhere on your property. Ranges vary from about 1600 feet to 3300 feet. Consider the method of correction you prefer, between pressing the button yourself and collars that do the work for you when triggered (typically used for barking correction). Make sure the collar is waterproof if you play outside in all types of weather. And also check the battery life — some vibrating dog collars need to be charged every few days while others last up to 20.
Last but not least, consider your pet’s personality and the behaviors they are currently struggling with. If only small changes need to be made, any collar should do the trick. But if your pet is more stubborn than most or requires serious correction, you may need a product with several vibration levels. You can start at the lowest one and work your way up until the behavior has come to an end.
Paipaitek vibrating dog collar
This vibrating dog collar makes pet training simple. It comes with a remote and a keychain clicker, so you can address concerning behaviors from anywhere. The signal range is 3300 feet, so it’s no big deal if your pup is across the yard from you when something goes wrong. The levels go from 1 to 100, giving you tons of wiggle room to adjust to your pet’s needs. The collar itself is waterproof for rainy days or swimming adventures, too.
Pros:
- Average price point
- Prong-free
- Long-lasting battery works for up to 20 days
- Ideal for pets that weigh 4-120 pounds
- Same remote can be used for up to 3 collars for multi-pet homes
Cons:
- Makes a beeping sound when powered on, which some dogs don’t appreciate
PetJoy vibrating dog collar
This training collar provides a combination of vibrations and beeps to gently remind your pet to do the right thing. It has ten strength levels for each of the following modes: beep, vibration, and beep/vibration combined. The collar is weatherproof for outdoor play and works from distances up to 1500 feet away from the receiver. Both the remote and the collar are rechargeable, with the collar lasting around 20 days and the remote lasting up to 180.
Pros:
- Low price
- USB charging cable included
- Can be used on dogs 4-150 pounds
- Submersible for swimming and baths
Cons:
- Best suited for small and medium-sized breeds
Brapezie vibrating dog collar
This unique dog collar has built-in LED lights, making it easier to spot your pup outside at night. The light can also be used as an extremely gentle training method. Other training modes include beeps and vibrations. Each type has 16 levels, so you can start with the lowest and work your way up as needed. The collar works from up to 2000 feet away. The battery lasts for about 15 days, while the receiver battery lasts closer to 45. The slim remote is comfortable to hold and the LED screen makes setting selection a breeze.
Pros:
- Reasonable price
- Fits dogs 20-110 pounds
- “Lost mode” makes the light blink if your pet wanders off at night
- Built-in lock on remote prevents accidental punishments
Cons:
- Charging port must be closed for the collar to be waterproof
Paipaitek vibrating dog collars, 2 pack
If you are training more than one dog, this two-pack of vibrating collars could make life simpler. Both collars can be controlled by the same remote — just choose “dog 1” or “dog 2” before sending signals. The correction methods include beep, vibration, and beep/vibration combined. The remote works from 1600 feet away, so you don’t have to stay right next to two dogs at the same time. And the collars are completely waterproof for rainy days, swimming, or bath time.
Pros:
- Affordable
- Lightweight remote control
- 20-day battery life
- Recharge via USB
Cons:
- Vibrations may be slightly gentler than other collars
StopWoofer vibrating dog collar
This vibrating collar strives to prevent nuisance barking. Instead of having to press a button on a remote every time you need to correct the behavior, it vibrates and beeps at the sound of your pet’s voice. It can be put on your dog during the times when he is not supposed to bark and taken off when he may need to make noise to protect you. There are 7 levels of correction, which cycle through automatically depending on how well your pet is listening. And if they keep barking even when their collar is on, the device will turn off after 1 minute to prevent extensive punishment. It’s easy to charge the collar via USB and it lasts for around 14 days between power-ups.
Pros:
- Fair price
- Typically produces results within two weeks
- Highly adjustable strap
- No training effort is required on your part
Cons:
- Only for correcting excessive barking
Frequently Asked Questions
Are vibrating dog collars humane?
Yes. Vibrating dog collars do not cause pain. They deliver a vibration that dogs do not enjoy, but it does not hurt them. This vibration can be used on very low levels, almost like a reminder to dogs that their behavior wasn’t desirable. Vibrating collars can be paired with praise training as well — give your pup a training treat when they do as the collar asked. You may even want to reward them with something larger, like a bully stick, when they make a significant positive change.
Do vibrating dog collars work as well as shock collars?
For many dogs, vibrating dog collars can work just as well or even better than shock collars. They typically do not cause the fear and anxiety that can come with pain-based training. They do require consistency to be effective, but that is true of all forms of dog training.
Do I need to use a vibrating dog collar forever?
No. Vibrating dog collars can be used during the training process and removed once your pet understands the appropriate action.
If I have multiple pets, do they each need their own vibrating dog collar?
Yes, if you are training both pets at the same time. You may want to purchase a two-dog pack to save some money and simplify the dog training tools you have at home.
What types of behaviors can vibrating dog collars correct?
These products are often used to help dogs stop barking, though dog barking collars exist for this purpose as well. Vibrating collars can also be used to prevent other nuisance behaviors, such as stealing food, jumping on people, tables, or counters, pulling on a leash, chasing other pets, and more.
About the Author
Why Trust Us
Since 2008, DogTime has served as a leading resource for millions of dog owners and pet lovers alike. Our goal is to give every dog and pet a happy, healthy home by providing owners with all the information they need to be the best pet parents possible. Our experts share their insights and recommendations to make caring for your beloved pets a breeze.