The Best Gentle Leaders for Dogs

While we love to watch our canine friends enjoy themselves unencumbered, distractions are always just around the corner. Cue the random squirrel, the neighborhood cat, or another dog on a walk. We all know that dogs are playful. And while they relish the opportunity to chase something other than a tennis ball, it's often safer for everyone if they remain on a leash when out. With that in mind, here are the best gentle dog leaders that allow your pup to have a carefree outing while still remaining safely within reach.

What to Look For

Like a good dog leash, the best leaders should be durably made, appropriately sized, and comfortable enough for your pup to wear on walks long and short. We think one of the best leaders out is from PetSafe, which makes a flexible nylon model that is ideal for dogs of all shapes and sizes. If you’re looking to keep your pup extra comfortable, we also recommend the halter from Goodboy, which incorporates extra padding around the snout to prevent any chaffing or irritation. Read on to discover more of our favorite gentle leaders and to find one that’s right for your canine companion.

PetSafe Gentle Leader No-Pull Dog Collar

Control without constricting

This gentle, no-pull collar ensures both you and your dog will have a fun and safe outing.
Best Overall

Find on Amazon

We all want our dogs to have fun on their walks. Still, every now and then, a leisurely stroll can turn hectic due to a sprinting squirrel, an outdoor cat, or a random bird. Odds are good that your dog will run, lunge, or bark at these cute creatures. That’s where this pick comes in handy. The keyword here is “gentle.” When your dog shifts into hyper mode, you want to be in control of the situation, but you also want to make sure that your pet isn’t being choked. This collar assures that your canine companion will experience minimal discomfort. With no pressure being applied to the throat, this leader really is the best overall, as it allows your dog full range of motion while letting you remain in control of any unwanted behavior.

Pros:

  • Not only is it gentler on their necks, but this leader can also eliminate pulling entirely. Dogs have an aversion to straining against a collar that pulls on their snouts, so the results can be almost immediate.
  • Even if your dog does continue to pull, the padded neoprene nose loop does a good job at preventing choking and gagging.
  • The price is really affordable, so it’s perfect for dog owners with tight budgets.

Cons:

  • You have to be very careful to get the right size and adjustments, otherwise, it won’t work properly.

GoodBoy Dog Head Halter with Safety Strap

For sensitive snouts

With lots of padding, this halter provides comfort and flexibility to what can otherwise be a restrictive accessory.
Best Padded

Find on Amazon

When we take our dogs out on a walk, we want them to be safe and comfortable. This head halter from GoodBoy provides exactly that: safety and comfort. With its optimal padding, you remain in control of any pulling and lunging while your dog safely abides. And thanks to the collar’s durable stitching, the strong nylon straps ensure that both you and your pet will experience a worry-free outdoor adventure.

Pros:

  • It’s ideal for those with extra-aggressive dogs that continue to pull even against these types of leaders.
  • The extra padding and neoprene materials feel soft and don’t cut into the skin.
  • Leaders like these are often difficult to adjust but this one is easy.

Cons:

  • The plastic clasp for tightening the padded strap can become undone if your dog rubs their snout on the ground.

PetSafe Chic Gentle Leader Headcollar

Colorful canines

This patterned pick certainly stands out from the competition.
Best Style

Find on Amazon

If you’re looking for a pick that stands out from the pack, this is certainly the one. Designed with a whimsical dogbone print on the entirety of the collar, this pick isn’t just reliable, but it’s cute, too. Though Spot likely isn’t going to have a style preference one way or another, you may find this pick’s unique print to be a selling point. Aside from the cool look, it also features all the design elements you’d look for in a quality headcollar, such as an adjustable nose loop and a quick-snap neck strap to help you get the fit just right.

Pros:

  • The different patterns and colors can attract a lot of compliments at the dog park.
  • Great for dogs of all ages, this fantastic leader can have instant results for rambunctious pups and serial leash-pullers.

Cons:

  • It may take some trial-and-error to figure out how to adjust it and put it on quickly.

Wintchuk Dog Harness with Padded Fabric

Halter your hound

Providing maximum comfort, this harness gives your dog's jaw the most freedom of movement.
Most Ergonomic

Find on Amazon

When deciding on the right harness for your dog, you have to take comfort into account. With a padded nose loop and adjustable nylon strap, this harness provides not only comfort, but also flexibility for your dog to pant, yawn, and drink. The soft texture also prevents skin abrasions.

Pros:

  • We love how sturdy and durable the safety buckle is. It retains the adjustment, which means we don’t have to adjust it anew every time we take our dog for a walk.
  • The thick materials resist wear and tear, so it’s built to last a long time.

Cons:

  • It’s bulky compared to most non-padded options.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are there advantages to using a gentle leader/harness over a leash?

Absolutely. A leash can choke your dog. We’ve all seen an excited dog panting and gasping for air while being hooked up to a leash. It’s unpleasant for everyone involved — especially the dog. A gentle leader or harness prevents choking while allowing you to easily control an excited or overeager pup.

What key elements should I look for in a harness?

Comfort is important. You want to make sure there’s enough padding around the harness so that skin irritation doesn’t occur. Most harnesses come with extra padding, but some don’t.

Proper sizing is also essential. The harness should be firm, but not constrictive. Your dog should be able to pant, yawn, and drink easily while you still have control of any situation that may present itself.

About the Author

Growing up around big dogs, like Collies and Dobermans, Madeleine developed a big appreciation for the care that canines require. These days, she volunteers at a local shelter, where she walks dogs of all sizes. She hopes to share her expertise with dog owners new and old to help them give their canines the quality care they deserve.

Why Trust Us

Since 2008, DogTime has served as a leading resource for millions of dog owners and pet lovers alike. Our goal is to give every dog and pet a happy, healthy home by providing owners with all the information they need to be the best pet parents possible. Our experts share their insights and recommendations to make caring for your beloved pets a breeze.