The 5 Best Stuffed Dog Toys For Comfort And Play
Most dogs love to have a stuffed toy to chew on, snuggle with, and toss around. That's why we've compiled this list of the five best stuffed dog toys, so you can pick the perfect pal for your pooch.
Whether your dog is a puppy or a senior, one of the best stuffed toys can be fun and engaging. Not only can such toys help alleviate boredom, but they can also instill a sense of security and comfort for your pet. Indeed, we’ve had many dogs that grew a bond with their stuffed toys, providing them companionship for road trips and bedtime.
But choosing the right stuffed toy for your canine takes some consideration. Here, we present our research findings, with a slew of features that you should keep in mind. For example, we recommend dog toys made from non-toxic materials that can help ensure your dog’s safety and well-being. Additionally, you can find stuffed toys that are specifically designed to endure even the roughest play. Indeed, there’s a lot to consider, so let’s discuss the essentials.
Best Stuffed Dog Toys to Consider
When shopping for stuffed dog toys, there are several important considerations to keep in mind to ensure you’re choosing a high-quality toy that’s safe for your pet to play with.
First and foremost, it’s essential to choose a toy made from quality materials. Look for dog toys made from durable components that can withstand rough play and won’t easily tear or break. Toys made from non-toxic materials are also essential to ensure your dog’s safety. Also, we recommend avoiding toys with small hard parts, as these could present a potential choking hazard.
Another important factor to consider is the size of the toy. It should be appropriate for the size of your dog to ensure that they can play with it comfortably and safely. Larger dogs may need larger toys that can withstand their strength and weight, while smaller dogs may prefer little toys that are easier to carry and play with.
Furthermore, some dogs favor toys with different textures or sounds, while others may enjoy toys that are scented with familiar smells. There are even some options that are designed specifically to clean your dog’s teeth and gums while they play, making them a great choice for dogs who need extra dental care.
Finally, consider the overall design and style of the toy. Choose a toy that’s visually appealing and matches your dog’s personality and preferences. Toys with bright colors or unique designs can be particularly engaging for dogs, while toys that resemble familiar objects, like balls or bones, may be more comforting for your pet.
With these factors in mind, let’s dive into the reviews of the five best stuffed dog toys on Amazon.
Outward Hound Kyjen Hedgehogz Squeak Toy for Dogs
This pick from Outward Hound is a fantastic option for pet owners looking for a fun and engaging toy for their furry friend. Made with durable and high-quality materials, this toy is built to withstand rough play and will provide hours of entertainment for your pet. We love that it features a unique hedgehog design and a built-in squeaker that’s sure to capture your dog’s attention. Plus, the soft and plush texture of the toy makes it perfect for snuggling and cuddling. With its adorable design and high-quality construction, the Kyjen Hedgehogz Squeak Toy is a great choice for pet owners looking for a toy that’s both fun and durable.
Pros:
- Super inexpensive
- Durable construction
- Inner squeak adds to the fun
- Nice middle-ground size for most dogs
Cons:
- Playing tug of war with it will likely eventually lead to a tear
Multipet Gumby Plush Filled Dog Toy, Green
When we discovered Multipet’s Gumby stuffed toy, we were blown away. The price is incredible, considering the number of hours of entertainment this 9-inch toy can provide, especially since it holds up well to aggressive chewers. Better yet, the plush, soft feel makes a fast friend, so many dogs prefer to cuddle with it rather than tear it apart. But even for aggressive playtime, you can play tug-of-war for a long time before it starts to show signs of wear and tear.
We even recommend buying several since they’re incredibly affordable. Having a couple around the house on hand is an excellent way to help your dog let off some steam, and a couple of backups is never a bad idea. Best of all, Multipet offers other adorable models that serve the same purpose, and they’re all equally inexpensive and quality.
Pros:
- Only costs a couple of bucks
- Great for cuddling
- No hard plastic parts
- Super soft
Cons:
- This option is only 9 inches long, so larger dogs might prefer the larger size
Best Pet Supplies Stuffless Squeaky Dog Toy, Wild Duck
While we still consider this a stuffed toy, this squeaky mallard from Best Pet Supplies actually has none of the messy cotton fillings that can spill everywhere. In other words, you can let your dog go to town on this toy without worrying about busting a seam and spreading cotton fluff all over the house. It’s thus perfect for teething puppies and active play. Our favorite feature, however, is the inner pocket which lets you place a plastic water bottle to add some crunch and feedback to playtime.
This is also another budget-friendly option. In fact, Best Pet Supplies offers a wide range of animals, from squirrels to foxes to rabbits, and they’re all just as affordable and adorable as the last. This offers a great way to stock up on different animal toys to make sure your canine companion stays occupied.
Pros:
- Inexpensive
- No filling, so it won’t make a mess if it should tear
- Available in different designs and sizes to match your dog’s preferences
- Inner pocket for placing a water bottle or treats
Cons:
- If you place a water bottle inside, you have to monitor your dog to make sure they don’t ingest any plastics
goDog Checkers Elephant Squeaky Dog Toy, Chew Guard Technology
Some of us have dogs, while some of us have absolute destruction machines. If your furry friend tears apart every toy you give them, consider this squeaky dog toy from goDog. It has Chew Guard Technology, which gives it unmatched durability in the face of tenacious canine teeth. It’s essentially an extra reinforced lining and hidden seams which resist tearing. Add to that the plushy texture and inner squeaker, and you have a toy that’s built to last through hours of play.
Of course, it’s not indestructible. Certain models have long ears or limbs that might get pulled off in the long run. Still, we’ve found that these toys can endure well over a year of rough play, and the low price only adds to the value. Choose from any number of cute animal models, including “Fat Rooster” and “Flying Pig,” to add some personality to playtime.
Pros:
- Wide range of colors, sizes, and design options
- A great choice for destructive dogs
- The squeaker is effective and not too annoying
- Free of hard plastic parts to reduce choking risk
Cons:
- Some designs are more long-lasting than others, depending on the model
DODODOLA Durable Plush Dog Toy With Crinkle Paper
Just like human kids, all puppies need a pal. This plush toy from DODODOLA delivers the cuddly companionship that every dog needs, and it does it for a super low price. This particular model is an elephant, though DODODOLA has other designs, too, like dinosaurs and hippos. Whichever stuffed animal you choose, there’s a good chance your dog will form a fast friendship with it.
We recommend this option for puppies since teething dogs seem to adore gnawing on the ears. That’s because it also contains crinkle paper, which combines with the squeaky toy to add a new level of interactiveness. However, the medium size offers plenty to chew on for larger dogs as well. Whether this crunchy elephant serves as your dog’s newest plaything or snuggle buddy, it’s sure to please.
Pros:
- Exceptionally cute
- Contains both crinkle paper and squeaker
- Made with an air mesh that helps add durability and fluffiness
- Safe materials
Cons:
- Probably not durable enough to endure very large aggressive dogs
Frequently Asked Questions
Are stuffed dog toys safe for my pet to play with?
Yes, stuffed dog toys can be safe for your pet to play with, but choosing a high-quality toy made with durable and non-toxic materials is tantamount. It’s best to avoid toys with small parts that can be easily swallowed and always supervise your pet during playtime to ensure their safety.
How do I clean my dog’s stuffed toys?
It is best to follow the cleaning instructions provided by the manufacturer. In general, most stuffed dog toys can be washed in the washing machine using a mild detergent and then air-dried. Avoid using harsh chemicals, like bleach, as these can damage the toy and potentially harm your pet.
What should I consider when choosing a stuffed dog toy?
When choosing a stuffed dog toy, you should keep in mind your pet’s size, play style, and chewing habits. Look for options that are appropriate for your pet’s size and energy level, and choose toys made with durable components that can withstand rough play. It is also important to consider your pet’s preferences, such as toys with squeakers or toys that can be cuddled and snuggled.
How can I prevent my dog from destroying their stuffed toys?
Providing your pet with plenty of toys to choose from can help prevent them from becoming bored and destructive. Choose toys that are appropriate for your pet’s size and strength, and avoid leaving them with toys unsupervised. It is also worthwhile to provide your pet with plenty of exercise and mental stimulation to help channel their energy and prevent destructive behavior.
About the Author
Why Trust Us
Since 2008, DogTime has served as a leading resource for millions of dog owners and pet lovers alike. Our goal is to give every dog and pet a happy, healthy home by providing owners with all the information they need to be the best pet parents possible. Our experts share their insights and recommendations to make caring for your beloved pets a breeze.