Update: Missouri's Prop B rewritten in favor of breeders

Leslie Smith Editor in Chief of DogTime.com
Leslie Smith, Editor in Chief
Thursday April 14th, 2011
  • Share on Facebook

Column_puppy-mills_medium

Confession: I'm confused by the revisions to Prop B that came out of yesterday's congressional assembly in Missouri. On Wednesday, the House voted 85 to 71 to alter the Puppy Mill Cruelty Prevention Act, which Missouri citizens passed last November. The revised bill now heads to Governor Jay Nixon's desk.

A couple of the revisions seem like ok ideas, like higher licensing fees for breeders. But most of the changes appear to protect the people in the business of breeding, rather than the animals themselves. Changes like eliminating minimum requirements for the dogs' living conditions (i.e., "sufficient" space to exercise), loosening rules around veterinary care, and reducing criminal law penalties for violations.

Opponents of Prop B are pleased with the rewrites. They say that animal welfare advocates don't know what they're talking about when it comes to breeding dogs. They say we have laws - better than Prop B - already on the books.

So here's why I'm confused: If the current laws are so effective, why are puppy mills - with abhorrent conditions and sick animals - flourishing? And if breeders are already providing humane care for their animals, why is their so much opposition to laws requiring humane care for animals?

If I were a senator in Jefferson City right now, I might introduce a bill that places a moratorium on all dog breeding - at least until we're no longer euthanizing 10,000 shelter animals every single day in this country. I might require breeders to volunteer one afternoon a week in their local shelter, perhaps their duties could include walking each unwanted dog from his kennel to the euthanasia quarters. I might suggest that breeders spend a week - no, a month! No, a year! - living in the same conditions they provide for their dogs with similar limits as far as access to toilets, water, and room to lie down.

Something tells me I wouldn't get elected in Missouri.

More dog Content
Anonymous

If these breeders are as ethical as they claim, than why do they never allow you you to see their facilities. It's not until someone uncovers these horrible conditions that these poor animals must live in, does someone try an do something about it. It's funny how easily these so-called politicians can be swayed by the smell of money. Let them live in those conditions and be a breeding machine.....see what it feels like mister!!!

about 1 year ago by Anonymous

carolrhill101

This is beyond sad I sit here wanting to cry for each and every animal that being hurt for the sake of someone's botton line. How could they do this to innocent loving animals each and everyday and still go to sleep in peace I simply don't understand nor will I ever. This is why I hate politics because once they get into office everything they say is a lie.

about 1 year ago by carolrhill101

Rhonda C

You voted for the animals with this bill then against them by putting Republicans in charge, look at the voting records for the GOP on animal issues, it is public record and it aint pretty!

about 1 year ago by Rhonda C

Rhonda C

You voted for the animals with this bill then against them by putting Republicans in charge, look at the voting records for the GOP on animal issues, it is public record and it aint pretty!

about 1 year ago by Rhonda C

Recent conversations on these topics

  • Is safe/not living with a dog while I am pregnant?

    Is it safe to live with a dog while I am pregnant? As far as I know that prenatal development is very important. Everything can be a teratogen. Teratogens are substances that can harm my baby for instance dogs' hair. I have a story that is a true story. My doctor had two grandchildren who were deaf since they were born. He was trying so hard to heal his grandchildren, but unfortunetly, they could not be healed. He went to Singapore to check them up, and doctors in there told him that the cause was toxoplasma. My doctor's daughter used to have a lot of dogs inside her house. What do you think about this story? I want to know more about that because everthing has a possibility that we never know. I don't want to conduct an experiment with my own baby. That's why I am so curios. Thank you readers.

  • switching teams

    I worked at a vet clinic for sometime. We sold the veterinary level foods from several different brands. The kinds pets need when they have extreme food allergies or diabetic or renal care. This food is on the higher end of pet food price range. About twice as much as grocery grade foods. But still we regularly have people come in buying the best for their furry babies. One time, a man came in to pick up the renal food for "his wife's" cat. I think for the case of canned cat food the total was $24. He jokingly scoffs at the cost and hands me a credit card. Then he says, "I can't believe I'm spending this much on cat food. I never used to be a cat person. I didn't get them. I was a dog person. I understand dogs, they show you exactly what they're feeling and thinking. Who would want an animal that doesn't run up to you when you get home? But now that we've had these two cats, I get it. It's a different kind of love. It just took having them to understand it." I haven't worked at that clinic for a few years now but moments like that are still crisp and vivid in my mind. It sounds like a similar transition for your dad. Maybe it started as a quest for companionship but turned out to be such a close camaraderie. Congratulations to him on his newfound love and hopefully this will be a new point of connection for the two of you.

  • I wrote a song to help end animal abuse and raise money for non-profit groups

    I am an animal lover and musician. I wanted to find a way I could help animals and shelters, rescue groups, etc. So I wrote and recorded the song "It's Gotta Stop: The Animal Abuse Song". My goal is to have any animal related non-profit groups use the song to raise funds. My idea is to let them upload it as an MP3 or wave file where they could put it on their websites and let people download the song for a donation. Any thoughts? You can listen to the song at www.soundcloud.com/dogmom

  • Location to train trainers in Northern California

    Does anybody know of a school in the Northern California area that trains people to train dogs? I have experience in training Police Dogs, but I would like to go through a school and get a certificate. Thanks, Barry

Editor's Notepad
Square_50_column_screen_shot_2012-05-20_at_5.19.40_pm

by Leslie Smith on May 27th, 2012

Batgirl, rescued from Hurricane Katrina floods, had been looking for a home since 2005.

Square_50_pit-bull-refuses

by Leslie Smith on May 24th, 2012

A concerned human offered the male dog food and water as he remained nestled near his friend.

Square_50_screen_shot_2012-05-23_at_11.49.36_am

by Leslie Smith on May 23rd, 2012

Sgt. Nick B. was on patrol when he noticed the skinny dog, covered in mud, scavenging for food.

Square_50_chained_dog

by Leslie Smith on May 14th, 2012

For some, the issue of over-crowded shelters is easily fixed. Just stop the killing. Realistic?

See all Editorial Posts »
AD
Dear-tabby-meow-mix-300x90

Welcome to DogTime.com

DOGTIME LOGIN or SIGN UP

AD
AD