Renee: You have just said yourself, you don't know what a dog is trying to say to someone. The woman didn't do anything malicious, but remember that dogs don't communicate the same way people do. Her error was to approach a strange dog (in a strange setting that was probably pretty stressful to him) in a manner that's pretty intimidating to dogs. I didn't watch the clip but from reading about it I believe she either grabbed his face or leaned over him to pet him. Either one of those are no-no's in dog-speak.
Most dogs will try to get away from the scary person (fight vs. flight) but that dog was not in a position to get away so he chose to fight.
It's unfair to say that he's an awful dog when you only use human standards to judge what is awful and what is not. As people we are capable of understanding dog behavior. Dogs are not as advanced as us and so it is unfair to expect them to understand human behavior. As the superior species (intelligence-wise anyhow), it is our responsibility to communicate with them in a way they understand.
Also, you say that once a dog bites a human, he should be put to sleep. That's also rather unfair as you're essentially saying that dogs should never be allowed to defend themselves when they are scared. Dogs aren't like people...they only have certain tools at their disposal. A person, for example, can punch someone, shove someone away, kick someone, slap someone...we have options. Dogs don't. Their option is their teeth.
Just like people, dogs have thresholds. Some dogs have a very high tolerance, some dogs have a lower tolerance. For example...if someone is really making you mad, it might take more for you to punch this person in the face than it would for the guy next to you. That doesn't mean the guy next to you is a horrible person...it just means you're different.
It's not animals being treated better than humans, it's that animals can't be expected to understand the human world the way we understand it.
Think about it this way...how many mistakes would you make if you were expected to live by dog etiquette? After awhile you'll probably catch on and get most of it right...but you'll never be perfect and you'll eventually meet a dog that has a very low tolerance for mistakes. Is it right to say that you are awful for not understanding or awful for behaving the way it is natural for you to behave (in a human way)?
2 days ago by SDNB